These businesses publish collection-buying services. Accepted items differ; read each shop’s policy and arrange a visit when required. An inclusion does not guarantee an offer.
Browse the full directoryStart with a town, a region, or what you collect.
Current guide: Collection buyers. Clear all filters to explore the full directory.
Choose a regional loop, review each shop’s verified specialties, and open directions. Hours, inventory, buying interests, and event schedules can change, so call ahead before making a special trip.
Showing 7 of 33 shops
1102 Main Street, Belmar, NJ 07719
Belmar shop focused on modern and vintage sports cards, including autographs, rookies and inserts, with signed memorabilia and Pokémon also listed.
Call or email before bringing a collection for sale. Confirm event dates directly; the event page omits the year.
3400 Route 37 East, Toms River, NJ 08753
Sports and entertainment cards, new and vintage singles, signed memorabilia and collecting supplies. The shop buys collections and offers paid appraisals, including house calls by appointment.
The shop recommends calling ahead for Saturday and Sunday visits. Appraisals require an appointment; fees apply.
2025 Old Trenton Road, Store 5, Princeton Junction, NJ 08550
Sports cards, Pokémon and Magic singles and sealed products, with scheduled TCG events. The shop buys selected cards and sealed items for cash or credit and offers paid grading advice.
In West Windsor. For more than 10 cards to sell, send a list ahead or arrange a drop-off/evaluation; 10 or fewer may be brought in. Use email, Instagram or text for questions about specific cards.
118 S Broadway, South Amboy, NJ 08879
Trading card game shop with Pokémon, Magic, Lorcana, One Piece, Riftbound and Gundam singles, sealed products and supplies.
Confirm the full weekly schedule before visiting; published third-party opening times differ. Check the store’s events listings for play times.
55 Parsonage Road, Menlo Park Mall, Upper Level Nordstrom Wing, Edison, NJ 08837
Menlo Park Mall collectibles shop with toys, Funko figures, comics, Pokémon singles and other trading card games.
Upper level near Nordstrom. Call to confirm Friday/Saturday closing time and arrange collection-selling appointments. Collection buying requires an appointment.
74 North Main Street, Milltown, NJ 08850
Comic book and toy shop with back issues, new comics, collectible figures and a free pull-list service.
Comics and toys are the confirmed focus. The collection-buying line is (732) 744-4642; arrange home visits or collection evaluations directly.
1301 Chestnut St, Unit R, Emmaus, PA 18049
Emmaus shop for sports cards, Pokémon, memorabilia and collectibles, with a renovated store and collection buying and trades.
Visit Unit R on Chestnut Street in Emmaus. Call or text the current shop number before bringing a collection.
Plan the stop, then check with the shop. Hours, stock, events and grading arrangements can change. Verified specialties do not guarantee today’s inventory. Each branch counts as one shop location.
Claim or correct your listing, update official information, and submit verified specialties or services. Factual corrections are free.
Explore Featured Trail placement, collection-lead options, a current buying-bounty section, an improved website, or a future AI sales assistant for your shop.
